As someone who’s been testing and reviewing luggage for over a decade, I’ve had the pleasure of experiencing Herschel Supply Co.’s evolution from a hipster backpack brand to a serious contender in the luggage market. Founded in 2009 by brothers Jamie and Lyndon Cormack, the Vancouver-based company has steadily built its reputation by combining vintage aesthetics with modern functionality. Known for their signature minimalist design and attention to detail, Herschel has carved out a unique niche in the travel gear industry. In this comprehensive review, I’ll share my hands-on experience with their luggage line and help you determine if they’re worth your investment in 2025.

Key Takeaways

• Herschel luggage offers excellent value for money, with most pieces ranging from $100-300
• Their signature minimalist design combines style with functionality
• Durability is good for casual travelers but may not withstand frequent heavy use
• Water-resistant materials and reinforced corners are standard features
• Limited lifetime warranty covers manufacturing defects
• Perfect for weekend getaways and short business trips
• Exceptional organization features across all product lines
• Strong sustainability initiatives with recycled materials

Top Recommended Herschel Luggage

Herschel Supply Co. Heritage Softshell Carryon Luggage

The Herschel Supply Co. Heritage Softshell Carryon Luggage (37L) has quickly become my go-to luggage for both business and leisure trips. The eco-friendly design, crafted from 100% recycled post-consumer water bottles, speaks to my values while maintaining top-notch durability.

The 37L capacity is perfect for a few days’ worth of clothes and essentials, and the convenient split design allows for easy organization. The all-terrain wheels and multi-stage retractable trolley handle make navigating through crowded airports or uneven sidewalks a breeze. I also love the extra storage features, including the zippered front pocket with a key clip, mesh organizer, and internal storage sleeve.

After taking it on several international trips and short getaways, I can confidently say that it offers a smooth, organized, and stress-free travel experience. Plus, the reinforced corners and nylon base ensure it can withstand the rigors of travel while keeping my belongings safe and secure.

Herschel Novel Duffle

At first glance, the Herschel Novel Duffle may seem like a simple bag, but it quickly proves itself as a reliable travel companion. The 43L capacity is perfect for weekend getaways or a trip to the gym, offering ample space for all your essentials without feeling overly bulky.

The separate shoe compartment has been a game-changer, keeping dirty shoes away from clean clothes and preventing any unpleasant odors. I especially appreciate the padded, removable shoulder strap, it makes carrying even a fully-packed duffle a breeze, reducing shoulder strain on long treks. The waterproof zippered closure ensures my belongings stay dry, no matter the weather.

After several months of travel, this bag has held up beautifully with minimal wear. With its eco-friendly materials, comfortable carrying options, and functional design, the Herschel Novel Duffle is a durable and stylish choice for any short trip or daily commute.

Herschel Novel Duffle Tech

For extended trips, the Herschel Novel Duffle Tech in Ash Rose Tonal is an exceptional choice. Designed with both functionality and durability in mind, this duffle bag offers ample space for your essentials while maintaining a sleek, compact design. The standout feature is the fleece-lined laptop compartment, which ensures your tech stays safe and protected during your travels.

The bag’s storage options are superb, with a signature shoe compartment, front storage sleeves, and internal organizer pockets, keeping everything in its place and easily accessible. Whether you’re heading to work or embarking on a weekend adventure, this duffle adapts to your needs. The reinforced handles with magnetic snaps are sturdy, and the removable padded shoulder strap adds comfort, making it easy to carry, even when packed to the brim.

The rear luggage trolley strap is a thoughtful addition, allowing the duffle to seamlessly attach to your suitcase for easy travel. After months of use, the bag shows minimal wear, with the eco-friendly materials standing up well to daily use. Its smooth operation, versatile carrying options, and practical features make it a must-have for any modern traveler.

Herschel Heritage Duffle Luggage Bag

This Herschel Heritage Duffle Luggage Bag has quickly become my go-to for weekend trips and everyday use. The spacious 40L capacity is perfect for packing everything I need, and the U-shaped zippered opening makes it easy to access all my belongings without fuss.

The external front sleeve pocket is incredibly handy for stashing my passport and travel essentials, keeping everything within arm’s reach. I love that the bag is made from 100% recycled post-consumer water bottles, it’s both durable and eco-friendly. The water-resistant material has come in handy during unexpected weather, keeping my clothes and gadgets dry.

Whether I’m heading to the gym, a quick getaway, or just need a reliable bag for daily errands, this duffle has exceeded my expectations. The comfortable carrying options, including the removable shoulder strap, make it a versatile and practical choice for any occasion.

Deep Dive: What Makes Herschel Luggage Stand Out?

Design Philosophy

When considering luggage, style and functionality rarely go hand in hand. Herschel has taken it upon themselves to marry these two essential qualities in a way that few other brands achieve. Through countless tests, I’ve found that Herschel’s design philosophy stands out due to its sleek, modern aesthetic and its deep understanding of real-world needs. Their signature striped liner is more than just an eye-catching feature; it helps to enhance the interior organization by making it easier to find items, while also providing an additional layer of quality that elevates the feel of the bag.

For the modern traveler, Herschel luggage is more than just a practical tool, it’s a fashion statement. Clean lines, minimal branding, and attention to the smallest details show that the design team at Herschel truly understands what today’s travelers want: a luggage brand that is as stylish as it is functional, and that can hold up to the challenges of real-life travel, whether it’s navigating airport terminals or embarking on spontaneous weekend getaways.

Material Quality and Construction

A piece of luggage is only as good as the materials used to make it, and Herschel takes this very seriously. Whether you’re choosing their hardside or soft-sided luggage, Herschel incorporates the finest materials to ensure long-term durability. Their hardside suitcases use polycarbonate shells, which are incredibly resilient against scratches and dings. These cases are built to endure wear from frequent travels, and the polycarbonate construction provides a flexible yet sturdy surface.

Meanwhile, the soft-sided options incorporate high-quality ballistic nylon or polyester, which offer strength, longevity, and resistance to the elements. Herschel’s commitment to durability is evident in the following features:

• Reinforced Stitching at Stress Points: This small but critical detail prevents any potential weak spots that could lead to damage during your travels, especially when the luggage is packed to its maximum.
• YKK Zippers: Known for their reliability, YKK zippers are the industry standard for smooth operation and longevity, even under heavy use.
• Custom-Designed Hardware: Herschel keeps branding minimal, focusing on sleek and functional hardware designed to stand the test of time.
• Water-Resistant Coatings: The fabric used in their luggage comes with water-resistant treatments that shield contents from rain, spills, or other moisture-related mishaps.
• Sealed Wheel Bearings: Herschel’s wheels glide effortlessly and quietly, even over rough terrain, thanks to the sealed bearings designed for maximum longevity.
• Impact-Resistant Corner Protectors: The corners of your luggage endure the brunt of the wear and tear from handling, so Herschel reinforces these areas with protective corners to preserve the structure and appearance of your bag.

These features speak to Herschel’s commitment to providing luggage that lasts through the long haul.

Practical Features and Innovation

Herschel stands out by understanding the traveler’s full journey, not just the act of packing. Their luggage is designed with innovative features that enhance the travel experience. For instance, waterproof zippered pockets protect electronics from moisture, while the padded laptop sleeve offers secure storage on the go.

A removable laundry bag keeps dirty clothes separate, making it perfect for frequent travelers. Key features across Herschel’s luggage include:

• Tech Compartments with Cable Management: Keeps gadgets and accessories organized and cords tangle-free.
• Expandable Compartments: Adds flexibility for extra items or souvenirs.
• Internal Mesh Dividers: Helps keep clothes, toiletries, and accessories organized.
• Compression Straps: Secure and compress items to prevent shifting during travel.
• Hidden Security Pockets: Discreetly stores valuables like passports and wallets.
• TSA-Approved Locks: Integrated locks on hardside models for secure and easy travel.

These practical features make Herschel luggage a reliable and efficient choice for travelers seeking style and functionality.

Value Proposition and Market Position

While many luggage brands focus solely on premium price points or low-budget offerings, Herschel occupies a sweet spot in the middle. Their luggage stands out as affordable yet premium in quality, offering travelers the perfect balance between style, functionality, and price.

Herschel has recognized that most travelers seek luggage that is stylish, functional, and affordable, without the steep price tags of high-end brands like Rimowa or Tumi. The brand’s price points reflect that ethos, offering high-quality luggage at competitive prices:

• Carry-On Luggage: $150-200
• Checked Bags: $200-300
• Duffel Bags: $80-120
• Backpacks: $50-150

Given the quality, design, and durability, Herschel offers great value for travelers who want reliable luggage without the luxury price tag. For those who are looking for something that feels premium but doesn’t cost a premium, Herschel presents an excellent option that performs well on a consistent basis.

Durability Overview and Long-Term Testing

As with any luggage, durability is one of the most important factors when deciding which brand to trust. Herschel luggage has held up impressively well over time. Whether on a short weekend getaway or a lengthy international trip, these bags stand strong against the tests of time. However, like any product, Herschel luggage does have a few areas where wear and tear may show over extended use. Here’s a closer look at how they hold up long-term:

• Hardside Cases: These suitcases are built to maintain their structural integrity even after multiple trips. They may show a few scuffs, but the polycarbonate shell is resistant to deep scratches.
• Fabric Options: Herschel’s fabric options, whether it’s the ballistic nylon or recycled polyester, show minimal signs of wear after regular use. There’s no significant fading, fraying, or breakdown of the fabric even after heavy travel.
• Wheels: The wheels are durable, though frequent use over rough terrain may cause some wear. On average, they last 2-3 years before requiring maintenance.
• Handles and Straps: Despite heavy loads and regular use, the handles and straps show no signs of weakness. They retain their strength and can comfortably handle the weight of a fully packed bag.
• Internal Organizers: The internal organizers hold their shape well, ensuring that everything stays in place during travel. Whether it’s the mesh dividers or compression straps, they stay intact and effective for long-term use.
• Water Resistance: Herschel’s water-resistant fabrics maintain their effectiveness, ensuring that contents stay dry, even after exposure to rain or spills.

Sustainability Initiatives

Sustainability has become a central concern for many travelers today, and Herschel is responding with initiatives that make their products both eco-friendly and responsible. They are actively working to minimize their environmental footprint and reduce waste. Some of their sustainable efforts include:

• Recycled Polyester: Herschel uses recycled polyester in select luggage models, helping to keep plastic waste out of landfills and providing a more eco-friendly material choice.
• Reducing Packaging Waste: They’ve made significant strides in minimizing packaging waste by reducing the overall size of their packaging and using recyclable materials.
• Water-Based Adhesives: Herschel has transitioned to water-based adhesives in many of their products to minimize the use of harmful chemicals and reduce environmental impact.
• Eco-Friendly Dyeing Processes: The dyes used in the manufacturing process are now eco-friendly, reducing the negative impact on the environment caused by traditional dyeing methods.
• Repair Programs: To reduce waste, Herschel offers a repair program to extend the life of their products. Instead of throwing away a damaged bag, travelers can send it back for repairs, keeping their luggage in service for longer.
• Sustainable Manufacturing: Herschel adheres to sustainable manufacturing practices, ensuring that their production process is as environmentally friendly as possible.

For those who care about the environment, Herschel’s commitment to sustainability ensures that each purchase is not just a wise investment in quality travel gear but also a conscious choice for the planet.

Conclusion

After thoroughly testing Herschel’s luggage line, I can confidently recommend them for casual to regular travelers who appreciate style and functionality. While they may not be the ultimate choice for road warriors who fly weekly, their combination of design, features, and price point make them an excellent choice for most users.

The sweet spot in their lineup is definitely their carry-on options and weekender bags, where their design excellence really shines. For checked luggage, while it’s still good, you might find better value in other brands depending on your specific needs.

Their commitment to sustainability, coupled with practical features and stylish design, positions them well in the modern travel market. As they continue to innovate and expand their line, I expect to see even more impressive offerings in the future.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How does Herschel’s warranty process work?

A: Based on my experience, their limited lifetime warranty covers manufacturing defects but not normal wear and tear or accident damage. The process involves submitting photos and a claim form online, with response times typically within 48 hours. I’ve found their customer service to be responsive and fair in handling claims.

Q: Are Herschel suitcases water-resistant?

A: Yes, both their hard-sided and soft-sided luggage offer good water resistance. The hard-sided cases are naturally water-resistant, while the soft-sided options feature water-resistant coatings and materials. However, they’re not completely waterproof. I’ve tested them in light rain and brief exposure to heavier downpours without any interior damage.

Q: How do Herschel bags compare to other brands in the same price range?

A: In my assessment, Herschel offers superior design and comparable quality to brands like Samsonite and American Tourister in the same price range. They excel in aesthetics and organizational features but might lag slightly in wheel quality compared to some competitors. Their warranty service and customer support are generally better than most brands in this price category.

Q: What’s the best Herschel bag for a weekend trip?

A: The Novel Duffle is my top recommendation for weekend trips. It offers the perfect size (42.5L capacity) and includes practical features like the shoe compartment. For those who prefer wheels, the Trade Carry-On is an excellent alternative. Both options offer enough space for 2-4 days of clothing while maintaining carry-on compliance.

Q: Do Herschel bags meet airline carry-on requirements?

A: Most Herschel carry-on bags comply with major airline requirements, but it’s worth noting that their Highland Carry-On might be too large for some stricter airlines, particularly on European carriers. Always check specific airline requirements before traveling. Their Trade Carry-On model is specifically designed to meet international carry-on standards.